Regarding the flat tax

When I received my first municipal tax bill in 2008, I remember being surprised at the existence and size of the flat taxes, which were increased since then and have recently begun to be reduced. Somewhere in the past, the Flat Tax Foxes got into the Kimberley Municipal Tax Henhouse. This taxpayer believes we should eliminate the flat taxes altogether. I’m not alone.

In general, Canadian tax systems are progressive ones. It is generally accepted that taxes increase with income and that it is reasonable that wealthier people pay a higher tax. The City of Kimberley property tax charges are based on a mill rate per thousand of assessed value. In 2016 (the last year I can find a tax notice for) that rate, for residential, was 0.0915235 % of the taxable value of the property.

In Kimberley, those who have cheaper smaller homes, with lower assessed values and generally lower incomes, pay tax at higher rates than those who own more expensive larger homes with higher assessed values and who generally have higher incomes. Folks in smaller homes are usually singles, young people starting out, or retired people, and are not usually the targets for higher tax rates.

To analyze the effect of the flat tax, I’ve compared the 2016 taxes on my 1 bedroom 1 bath home (assessed at $139,200) with homes assessed at twice, three times and four times that assessment and at $1 million. The table below explains.

The taxes on more expensive properties of 3, 4 and more times the value, should not be producing municipal taxes at a much lower rate than smaller homes. I am charged a rate of tax 53% more than a one-million-dollar house! One can reasonably assume that larger properties, with more occupants, larger lots, more cars, more everything, consume more of this city’s resources, not less.

If we were to compute in the water, sewer and garbage charges (all ‘flat taxes’), the distortion in charges would be even more extreme. Multi-bedroom homes with more bathrooms with large tubs and even hot tubs use more water and generate more sewage. They produce more garbage from more occupants. Yet they are charged the same as a one-bathroom house. That is unfair.

Wealthy folks are used to the Canadian proportionate tax systems. They shouldn’t be discouraged by our mill rate taxes; they are used to them elsewhere and can afford them more than lower income folks. In any event, it is doubtful that any increase in municipal taxes will deter the building of large homes, given that land is relatively cheap in Kimberley. Incidentally, rather than encouraging large homes, climate issues mean we should be encouraging smaller homes.

For taxes to be acceptable, they must be fair and be seen to be fair. Kimberley’s flat tax system produces unfair results. Owners of smaller homes should not be subsidizing large homes. It is right and fair to proceed towards eliminating the flat tax.

Incidentally, the taxes on an average home in Fernie, Invermere, Kelowna, Rossland and Nelson are all higher than on an average Kimberley home.

John Allen

430 Wallinger Ave

Just Posted

Kimberley and District Community Foundation seeks ‘friends’

In the next couple of weeks, members of the Kimberley & District… Continue reading

The shootout at the Bechtel Ferry: 1945

On August 24, 1945, Charles Bechtel, age 66, was killed by the BC Provincial Police just south of the ranch.

Kimberley City Council approves development permit for 12-unit rental housing complex on Church Ave

The Kimberley Seniors Project Society has been waiting years to make this project a reality.

Hospice seeks clients for Live & Learn Program

After a successful two-year trial period, the Cranbrook and Kimberley Hospice Society is renewing its Live and Learn day program, and is putting out the word to prospective clients.

Kimberley Chamber planning for future

Strategic planning has led to exciting ideas, says Board member Karen Rempel

Kimberley news recap

A quick recap of the top news stories in Kimberley this week.

Rookie Demko backstops Canucks to 4-3 win over Sabres

Young Vancouver goalie makes 36 saves to turn away Buffalo

Charges upgraded against mother of murdered B.C. girl

Kerryann Lewis now faces first- rather than second-degree murder in the death of Aaliyah Rosa.

UPDATE: Injured firefighter in stable condition

Kelowna fire crews responded to a blaze at Pope’sGallery of BC Art & Photography on Friday

Rare ‘super blood wolf moon’ takes to the skies this Sunday

Celestial event happens only three times this century

Arrest made after historic B.C. church hit by arson

The fire at the 150-year-old Murray United Church in Merritt was considered a possible hate crime

B.C. dangerous offender in court for violating no-contact order, sends letter to victim

Wayne Belleville was shocked to see a letter addressed to him from his shooter, Ronald Teneycke

Crowsnest Pass RCMP seek help locating missing man

58-year-old Stuart David Duff was last seen on Jan. 6, 2019.

Man blames his loud car radio, sirens for crash with B.C. ambulance

Tribunal rejects bid to recoup ICBC costs after crash deemed 100-per-cent his fault

Most Read